Showing posts with label 12b-1 fees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 12b-1 fees. Show all posts

Friday, October 23, 2009

The Index Fund Conundrum Inside Your 401(k)

I do a popular radio show every Friday morning with Gina and Kat on MomsMakingaMillion. Each week, the topic progresses a little closer to a full understanding about your 401(k) – if that could ever fully happen!

This week, the ladies asked me: You talked about the risk of too little risk last week. This week I understand you want to take a look inside a 401(k) plan. A friend of yours was having a problem.

Yes we did discuss risk and the risk of too little risk. But the real risk might be lurking not in how you invest but in where you put your money in your 401(k). In fact, what your plan offers may be so limited that your choices boil down to good and not-so-good.

Let’s start with this: Most common, garden variety 401(k) plans offer index funds, lifecycle funds and if you are fortunate, actively managed funds. Plans can be big and small with thousands of options or just a few.

Life cycle funds represent a group of offerings focused on a particular target year that you would like to retire. These are essentially actively managed funds that shift, at least in theory, from aggressive to conservative investments over the course of your career.

Actively managed funds tend to pick a sector, such as large-cap stocks, and focus their investment prowess to the best possible return.

Index funds are designed to track an index of stocks (or bonds), ranging from the top 500 companies to indexes that track the smallest.

But before I tell you about how index funds can differ (which might seem odd, considering an index fund essentially attempts to mimic the published index) I want to talk about a person who wrote me last week. Although her email sounded panicked, she knew that there was little she could do about what her 401(k) plan was doing to her portfolio.

She told me she had chosen four funds in her 410(k) to invest in, the bulk of which was directed towards a small cap index and a mid-cap index run by Merrill Lynch. She believed, and rightly so, that this would be where the recovery would take place. These funds had always done well she told me, and when the markets turned sour and her funds were brutally beaten down, she kept her investment dollars streaming in.

Because markets do recover and her investments remained consistent, her portfolio value is now within a couple of thousand dollars of her year end balance in 2007.

Her concern was a change her plan sponsor was making in those funds, switching to another group of funds offered by Northern Trust. The reason according to a notice she received from her plan sponsor was the cost of fees.

Focused on Fees
In general, index fees should be as low as possible and here is why.
The idea is simple:
1.There is no trading to be done between the time the index is set and the next time it is adjusted;
2.There are no research fees;
3.And inside your 401(k), there should be no 12b-1 fees (the cost of advertising for new investors paid for by the current investors);
4. And lastly, because the company, in her case it was Kroger, the fiduciary responsibility (what a plan sponsor does is based on the assumption that it is best for the employee's future) demands the best deal.

That would be in a perfect world. Not to pick on her company's plan, but it doesn't fair very well when they are searched for using BrightScope, a retirement plan quantifier (information about their invaluable service can be found here) and this had her worried. Just because she has a plan, doesn't make it the best of all worlds, simply the one she has to live with.

Her plan was shifting her small cap index fund (with an expense ratio of 0.15%) to one that offered to track the same index but at 0.06%. At first glimpse, this seems like a good move. Lower fees are always good. Second glances however show how poorly the new fund offering has done compared to what she had before. Her new fund has a year-to-date performance of 12.52%; her old fund had chalked up a 29.83% return. Year-to-date, the Russell 2000 index of small cap stocks has racked up an impressive 22.43%.

Why would they do this, she asked? Other than being able to suggest that they are trying to do all they should for you, substituting one index for another based simply on fees, there seemed to be no clear answer. It is troublesome to be sure but not uncommon. It is also evidence that not all indexes are created equal or cost the same.

Index funds are subject to all sorts of influences. Fees run the gamut from absurdly low to ridiculously high. There is also the pesky probability of tracking error, a problem some fund managers get into as they try to outperform the benchmark. This tends to increase the expense ratio by forcing more trades and increased research. But it might also allow the index to outperform.

Keep in mind, your index fund does not buy every stock being benchmarked. An S&P 500 index generally has only about 75% of the stocks on the list in the portfolio. How much of each is often the reason for the disparity in returns. A Russell 2000 index fund has only about a third of the companies listed.

Most people think of Vanguard Group when they think of index funds. But their much-touted S&P 500 index fund carries an expense ratio of 0.15%. My friend’s small-cap index fund, the one that did so well, charged her the same as this less risky S&P 500 index fund cost.

Add to that, there is relatively poor information available to her even through her plan. A great many of the funds offered inside your plan are not offered to individual investors making information gathering difficult. Plan information is improving but comparisons are still hard to make. She was more upset that no one asked her if she would like to switch.

Not All Plans are Created Equal
Looking inside your 401(k) is never easy. For Boomers (and anyone focused on retirement), it can be especially difficult. You are torn in many cases between necessary risk and the fear of that risk. Your portfolio may not have recovered as quickly as my friend's did but consider the option of too little risk as one not worth taking.

There are basically only two ways of achieving the goals you may have set. You could increase your risk and/or increase your contribution. If you do the later, you can use the additional funds to purchase something more conservative while leaving your original contributions, the funds directed towards more risk, intact.

You should remember that if your plan offers only index funds and lifecycle funds (target-date funds), chose the index offerings. If your plan offers choices beyond index funds, choose the actively managed funds across a range of disciplines (large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap and international). In some cases, the fees might even be as competitive as the index fund that tracks them.

In the end, my friend did nothing. She had one of those not-so-good plans. Her only option was to increase her contribution to make up for the unrealized returns.

Paul Petillo
Managing Editor/BlueCollarDollar.com

Thursday, March 13, 2008

Retirement Planning and Advertising

I have always marveled at the ingenuity employed by companies looking for your retirement dollars. They have portrayed it as a nest egg, picturing people wheeling around giant replicas of what they have amassed to secure their future. Although between you and me, retirement planning is more about the nest you build than the contents of what you put in it. Yet the image definitely has a certain stickiness to it.



Now the Dutch banking giant ING Groep has entered into the fray with their latest advertisement picturing a wide variety of people carrying around dollar based numbers. This new guilt trip offers a speculative look at how much money you will need in retirement. The bank’s message is designed to prompt everyone who has yet to save a nickel for retirement to take action.

The idea that some “hypothetical” number will prod you into saving more is not anything new. The advertising world has been very active in formulating the right spin on the topic. But I wonder if the costs of such campaigns, which are passed on to you in the form of fees, produce better investors.

I have spent a great deal of time talking about the high costs of investing in your future. My current book, the inspiration for this blog and the soon-to-be-launched website that accompanies it, looks at the numerous ways each step forward is taxed. Not in the sense the federal government taxes you but by the very companies that seek to make you rich – but not before they themselves take a cut of the action.

With mutual fund advertising, the 12b-1 fees offer a relatively straightforward assessment of what you will be charged by the fund company. You can pick among funds that charge their shareholders for campaigns to attract new investors by choosing the companies that charge little to nothing.

But once those funds get tucked inside of corporate sponsored retirement plans, the fee structure becomes more opaque. You should always ask: “why does the mutual fund offered in my 401(k) still charge a 12b-1 fee?”



Each fraction of a percentage point levied against your retirement savings means that, to achieve a target like ING suggests, you will need to save more. But saving more is only part of the equation. As I mention in the book, it takes a great deal of financial coordination to get where you think you should be (which I take the time to break down, one by one).

There are numerous forces at work chipping away at the effort and the fees, which ING does not mention in the ad – and why would they, are just a part of it. Beware the dangling carrot. It offers you the opportunity to chase what may never be yours.